The New DOCTOR WHO

March 7th, 2005 | brainjuice

Well, it’s better than that brainless monstrosity of a TV movie that poor old Paul McGann battled through.

And, for the comics readers in the audience, that is indisputably a Bryan Hitch-designed TARDIS interior.

Christopher Eccleston, as the Doctor, is a delight. I imagine he’ll settle down as the series progresses, but right now he’s a walking mood-swing — Tom Baker’s mad grin and sudden command, Jon Pertwee’s physicality, Patrick Troughton’s impish side. And he’s got a great old leather jacket. He keeps his Northern accent, and when his new assistant asks him why he sounds Northern when he’s an alien, writer Russell Davies gives him the fine line: “LOTS of planets have a North!”

I used to own a jacket like
this. I think a girl stole it.

Word is that Sci-Fi Channel declined to acquire this new DOCTOR WHO series. And I can see why. It’s too damned English. As Rich Johnston said to me tonight, it’s your actual English family sci-fi show. There’s no way it’d fit on Sci-Fi. I imagine, to be honest, it’s going to bypass much of the American audience, and possibly even the gap between my generation and my daughter’s generation.

It is, in fact, DOCTOR WHO, as it was, complete with fake jeopardy for the kids and laughs for the adults. It will probably disappoint old fans — and anyone looking for a BATTLESTAR GALACTICA-style treatment — because it resolutely refuses to take itself too seriously. It’s not afraid of doing gags like having a kid eaten by a marauding plastic rubbish bin because that’s all part of the ride, all part of the style. In Michael Moorcock’s phrase, it obeys and enjoys the genre.

And so you get that nice little counterpoint between strange comedy bits and straight dramatic moments that is the hallmark of a certain strain of British fiction. Showroom dummies (yes) coming to life and shooting people might look funny, and it is — but the bodies are just as dead. And that — the placing of an alien element into a naturalistic contemporary British context — is the signature of the old British sf style, from WAR OF THE WORLDS to DAY OF THE TRIFFIDS, from QUATERMASS AND THE PIT to, especially, DOCTOR WHO.

(For the old WHO watchers, this first story is a riff on the Autons, from back in the 70s.)

Billie Piper, best known over here for being a teenaged pap-pop singer and the (ex-)wife of ginger mini-media-mogul Chris Evans, is something of a revelation as the Doctor’s new assistant, Rose Tyler. She’s much better than anyone would expect. Eccleston’s a big actor. She does better than hold her own.

It’s shot on digital video, by the looks of it. The production values are, despite everything, a little ropey in places. Not the old cardboard walls and blokes in latex monster suits, though. The credit sequence is just horrible, the incidental music ranges from passable to fucking awful, and some of the gags don’t land at all. Davies works best in the naturalistic stuff, and in the interplay between the Doctor and Rose. That said, DOCTOR WHO hasn’t been this good since the early days of Peter Davison in the role. It’s nice to have it back, and I’m looking forward to watching it with my daughter when it airs on the BBC in a few weeks.

– W

54 Responses to “The New DOCTOR WHO”



  1. Doctor Who
    I’ve seen two reviews today of the first episode of the new Doctor Who series. I’m guessing that means that it’s available on the peer-to-peer networks. If anyone sees a b…



  2. Warren Ellis get a preview of the new Doctor Who
    Warrenellis.com � The New DOCTOR WHO…



  3. The British (Monsters) Are Coming
    We spent the weekend watching old Quatermass movies on DVD, all giddy with the news that the prof was heading back to our screens (as posted here). Now we hear that the new Doctor Who will bypass American audiences as it’s “too damned English” whic…




  4. “Nice to meet you Rose… run for your life!”
    I hate to admit it, but I’ve seen the leaked premier. After reading the glowing review on Warren Ellis’ blog, I couldn’t resist. Within the first 15 minutes, I knew what I was watching. Other than the lack of a…



  5. Doctor Who New Series 2005
    The first line under the picture here might indicate this is the only way that you ‘Merkins get to watch this.

    I’m still waiting for it to air ‘proper’. The Ecclestone trailer was on BBC2 last night for the first time. I was dead excited.



  6. The new Doctor Who
    I’ve been hearingthat the BBC is bringing back Doctor Who since … oh … right after they cancelled it, I think. But no, this time they really are, and Warren Ellis has seen it. Apparently it’s been released, intentionally or…

  7. online gambling
    Please check out the sites about free slots

  8. home mortgage calculator
    You may find it interesting to check the sites about credit card offers mortgage calculator

  9. hair loss treatment
    You may find it interesting to check some relevant pages about prescription drugs quit smoking

  10. blackjack
    Please check some information about blackjack

  11. .
    You are invited to check my blog too

  12. jack black
    Please check out some helpful info in the field of jack black craps

  13. Card Game
    Nice articles and comments on Card Game and other related issues. When you truely want to play Card Game look no further. Play here Card Game. Play more, gain more, http://www.card-game-trx.com never no more. The greatest Card Game of all. The diversit…

  14. Bingo Game
    Many features and gambling games, Bingo Game and such. Look at Bingo Game for rules and tips. The only reliable Bingo Game , in my opinion. I was resilient to add an http://www.bingo-game-trx.com at all to the site, because for all intensive purposes B…

  15. Bingo Game
    Many features and gambling games, Bingo Game and such. Look at Bingo Game for rules and tips. The only reliable Bingo Game , in my opinion. I was resilient to add an http://www.bingo-game-trx.com at all to the site, because for all intensive purposes B…

  16. Baccarat Game
    Many features and gambling games, Baccarat Game and such. Look at Baccarat Game for rules and tips. The only reliable Baccarat Game , in my opinion. Hi, you – heard of http://www.baccarat-game.net? Baccarat Game is just the right thing for you. Great s…

  17. Baccarat Game
    Many features and gambling games, Baccarat Game and such. Look at Baccarat Game for rules and tips. The only reliable Baccarat Game , in my opinion. Hi, you – heard of http://www.baccarat-game.net? Baccarat Game is just the right thing for you. Great s…

  18. Online Blackjack
    you probbably know now that Online Blackjack is one of the largest Online Blackjack on the internet. I truely believe that Online Blackjack games offers the most complete combination. Visit http://www.blackjack-trx.com games and play the game! The bigg…

  19. Online Blackjack
    you probbably know now that Online Blackjack is one of the largest Online Blackjack on the internet. I truely believe that Online Blackjack games offers the most complete combination. Visit http://www.blackjack-trx.com games and play the game! The bigg…

  20. Craps Strategy
    Craps Strategy with a name you can trust, Craps Strategy All our games are independently tested and with 24/7 customer support there will always be someone on hand to help you day or night. Many games, great Craps Strategy variety. A new http://www.cra…

  21. משקה משכר
    Thank you for your interest in משקה משכר. All things can be ordered directly from the web by choosing the משקה משכר gallery in which you like. Click on the …

  22. דרינק
    Our award-winning דרינק just got better with support for the Firefox browser! Thank you for your interest in דרינק you are doing a wonderful thing for your community! דרי…

  23. [...] I was particularly relieved when I found out that the newly written theme had not made it in time for this draft, but can be heard here if you’re curious. Also, if you’re in need of a spot-on, more spoilery review check out Warren Ellis’ site. [...]

  24. [...] I was particularly relieved when I found out that the newly written theme had not made it in time for this draft, but can be heard here if you’re curious. Also, if you’re in need of a spot-on, more spoilery review check out Warren Ellis’ site. [...]

  25. [...] Michael Curry (mcurry) wrote,@ 2005-03-06 22:40:00      Current mood: jealous Warren Ellis on the new Doctor Who series Warren Ellis talks about the new Doctor Who series here:http://www.warrenellis.com/index.php?p=433And yes, he actually seems to like it, which makes me sad that the SciFi channel declined to pick it up for the US. Not that, as Warren points out, it’d actually fit in with the rest of the stuff on SciFi. Which, imo, would have been a good thing.(Post a new comment) pbray 2005-03-07 04:13 am UTC (link) Wonder if it will ever make it to the BBC America channel? Or will they hold on to it hoping that Sci-Fi channel will change their minds.Though really, what can one expect from the network that is bringing us Mansquito? [...]

  26. [...] Warren Ellis talks about the new Doctor Who series here:http://www.warrenellis.com/index.php?p=433And yes, he actually seems to like it, which makes me sad that the SciFi channel declined to pick it up for the US. Not that, as Warren points out, it’d actually fit in with the rest of the stuff on SciFi. Which, imo, would have been a good thing. [...]

Coilhouse is Hiring! Apply Here.

Coilhouse - 08 Feb 10

Back around the time of Issue 03, we launched the Small Business Advertising Program to create affordable ad space for indie companies in the print version of Coilhouse. By the time Issue 04 rolled around, the number of advertisers had grown significantly – by this time, we had record labels, jewelry and clothing designers, sculptors, other magazines, web hosts, toy makers and graphic designers advertising in our pages. Click here to see them all. With editorial duties taking up more and more of our time as the weeks go by, the moment has come for us to seek help with the advertising side of running the magazine. We’re looking to hire an Ad Manager for our Small Business Advertising Program, starting with Coilhouse Magazine #05… and possibly subsequent issues.

Full details after the jump!


Read the rest of Coilhouse is Hiring! Apply Here.


Post tags: Coilhouse

Untitled Post

blissblog - 08 Feb 10

Untitled Post

blissblog - 08 Feb 10

Untitled Post

blissblog - 08 Feb 10

State of South Carolina Secretary of State Subversive Agent Form

jwz - 08 Feb 10

Check the appropriate box. Do you or your organization directly or indirectly advocate, advise, teach or practice the duty or necessity of controlling, seizing or overthrowing the government of the United States, the state of South Carolina or any political division thereof?
[ ] YES [ ] NO

If yes, please outline the fundamental beliefs. If applicable, attach a copy of the bylaws or minutes of meetings from the last year.

"Inflection Points" Presentation

Open The Future - 08 Feb 10

For those folks who are interested, here's the Slideshare version of the presentation I gave last week at the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute annual meeting. I was asked to talk about foresight thinking, as the event theme was "The Big One of 2056: What Went Right?" a look at a fictional 7.8 quake in the SF region that was handled as well as they could imagine possible.

My goal was to offer a bit of reassurance to the audience that there is some real utility to thinking about the future, and to spell out (in a cursory way) the kinds of big picture issues they should keep in mind while looking ahead forty-six years.

By and large, it was a successful talk. The post-talk questions were engaged, with little push-back, and I'm told that the overall response from the audience was quite positive.

The talk was video recorded, and I'm told will eventually be available to the public. I'll link when that happens.

CAN GIFTING ECONOMIES SCALE?

John Robb - 08 Feb 10

A gifting economy is different from a barter or market economy in that valuable items are given away to those that need them, without any quid pro quo, exchange, or payment.  Gifting economics (lots of great papers on this topic) were/are the economic heartbeat of hunter-gatherer tribal cultures, the social organization where we spent 99% of our time as homo sapiens sapiens.  Barter was, in contrast, a mechanism for economic interactions between tribes.  

This gifting economic system wasn't based on pure altruism.  It did have an enforcement mechanism to ensure compliance with the system over the longer term.  On the positive side, there was an intangible increase in the social status (using personal or societal metrics) of a tribal member that gifted an item.  On the negative, a failure to offer hospitality or gifts to those in need was considered a mortal slight that could incite violence or expulsion from the tribe.

There were also a considerable number of drivers for gifting at the tribal level.  Here are some:

  • The survival of the tribe, as a group, was more important than the survival of any individual.  However, the loss of any individual could put the tribe at risk.
  • The generation of surplus and innovation was highly uncertain.  Sharing reduced that uncertainty to manageable levels.
  • Sharing reduced internal friction that could put the tribe at risk.

Scalability

It's pretty clear that the societal drivers of tribal gifting economics and the mechanisms of enforcement didn't survive the transition to a global social system composed of billions of members.   Simply, the connections between any two individuals (outside of immediate familial relationships) are too abstract for these drivers and enforcement mechanisms to be relevant.   As a result, market based mechanisms for economic interaction have gained dominance.

However, the ongoing shift of the global market-based economy from a trade in rival goods (tangible items that invoke zero sum economics) to digital non-rival goods (items that can be copied at no expense or diminishment, endlessly) provides a window of opportunity.  It may be possible to revive gifting economics for non-rival goods to amazing beneficial effect.   Some ideas on how this could scale:

  • Automated reputation metrics that enhance social status based on contributions.
  • Mechanisms built using MMO gaming as a way to tie successful gifting to status improvement (leveling) or an ability to attract investment.
  • The creation of an inside/outside barrier that separates a gifting economy from the global economic mainstream.   Automated mutual interdependence (see my friend Bruce Sterling's absolutely brilliant story on this:  "Maneki Neko").

Latest on SNOW

Jean Snow - 08 Feb 10

Latest on SNOW

So what’s the latest on SNOW? I guess two new developments art that I added a dedicated Twitter feed, and also created a Facebook fan page. The Twitter feed is mostly just automated with new articles from the site — because some people actually prefer that over RSS feeds these days — but I do keep an eye on it, and will reply to questions and comments. The Facebook page is just another way of putting the site out there, and should be a good way of informing members of SNOW-related events as they happen.

Regular content updates have also continued over the past week, with a few new guest columns and my regular news items. Here’s a list of what you may have missed over the past few days.

Untitled Post

blissblog - 08 Feb 10

I Know It?s Over?

Kieron Gillen - 08 Feb 10